November 19, 2026
In the week of July 27, a 1,280-square-foot house at 110 19th Ave. in Belmar closed at $1,235,000. It had three bedrooms and one bathroom. In the week of Oct. 5, a 2,692-square-foot house at 101 River Court, also in Belmar, closed at $820,000 with four bedrooms and three bathrooms. The smaller house sold for $415,000 more. That works out to roughly $965 a square foot on 19th Avenue and roughly $305 on River Court.
If you've been comparing shore towns on the portals, Belmar's spread can be hard to make sense of. In Belmar, a sale price mostly measures the lot and where it sits. The house on it counts for less than in most Monmouth County towns. Once you read Belmar that way, the scattered prices line up, and you can tell a fair price from a tired one.
Belmar is built out. Its 2026 Master Plan Reexamination Report has the construction-permit history from the state Department of Community Affairs and the borough construction office. From 2004 through 2024, Belmar authorized 440 new residential units and issued 363 demolition permits, so after 21 years the borough netted 77 additional homes. Most of that net gain came from a few multifamily and mixed-use projects, with 2018 alone adding 84. Over the same span, one- and two-family construction totaled 267 units, about 100 fewer than the total number of demolitions. In 2024 the table shows one new one- or two-family unit and 11 demolitions.
That is how this market runs. Most building in Belmar replaces something that was already there, and in many of those years the town lost more structures than it gained. When the supply of lots is fixed and the houses on them keep getting replaced, a buyer is mostly paying for a place in line. The current house is one owner's use of that place.
A typical Belmar property is less tidy than "single-family home" suggests. Of the borough's 3,899 housing units, 444 are in two-unit structures, according to the 2024 American Community Survey estimates in the same report. Of the 940 units counted as vacant, 667 are held for seasonal, recreational or occasional use. Two-family houses, front houses with a second dwelling behind them, and summer places share the same blocks as year-round homes.
This fall's Zoning Board of Adjustment meetings show what owners are doing with those lots. One plan on 19th Avenue replaces a one-story house on a 3,050-square-foot lot with a new 2½-story single-family home and a detached one-car garage. The architect told the board the high water table rules out a basement, so the garage has to hold storage as well as a car. Another lot, on 12th Avenue, holds a two-family front house and a two-family rear house. Its plan started as a conversion of both to single-family homes and became a rebuild of the front house with one fewer bedroom. Belmar has a few blocks shaped by a single older project, too. A row of six homes on 4th Avenue came out of a 1992 Ocean Avenue subdivision of small lots with large homes, reached by an access lane behind them.
All of these cases run in one direction. Two-family houses become single-family homes, old one-story houses become 2½-story houses, and the number of homes holds steady or shrinks while the square footage grows. For a buyer, that explains the pricing. An older, smaller house on a well-placed lot is priced against what the next owner could put there and against the rebuilt houses already on the block.
NJ.com's weekly Monmouth County transfer roundups list reported residential property transfers, and their Belmar entries from the week of June 29 through the week of Oct. 26 give a sample of the season. Those sales run from $525,000 at 1809 Fernwood Road to $2,650,000 at 213 12th Ave. Sorted by price per square foot, the pattern is clear:
| Address | Transfer week, 2026 | Price | Sq. ft. | Approx. $/sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 110 19th Ave. | July 27–Aug. 2 | $1,235,000 | 1,280 | $965 |
| 106 17th Ave. | Aug. 3–9 | $1,700,000 | 1,792 | $949 |
| 1827 Laurel Terrace | Aug. 3–9 | $999,999 | 1,135 | $881 |
| 213 12th Ave. | Oct. 12–18 | $2,650,000 | 3,083 | $860 |
| 1715 White Street | Sept. 7–13 | $1,200,000 | 1,395 | $860 |
| 407 17th Ave. | June 29–July 5 | $1,600,000 | 2,111 | $758 |
| 1619 E Street | Oct. 19–25 | $850,000 | 1,284 | $662 |
| 227 14th Ave. | July 27–Aug. 2 | $1,400,000 | 2,352 | $595 |
| 1217 16th Ave. | Aug. 10–16 | $712,000 | 1,460 | $488 |
| 1202 Bayview Ave. | June 29–July 5 | $875,000 | 1,824 | $480 |
| 101 River Court | Oct. 5–11 | $820,000 | 2,692 | $305 |
A three-to-one spread in price per square foot within one small borough is what you'd expect when buyers are paying mostly for location. The most extreme case is 116 15th Ave., a two-bedroom, one-bath house that closed at $1,150,000 in the week of June 29. A buyer spending that much on two bedrooms is paying for the address.
Condos follow the same logic, except the building plays the role of the lot. At 1700 Main Street, Unit 310 sold for $695,000 in the week of June 29, about $477 a square foot, and Unit 208 sold for $607,000 in the week of Oct. 5, about $489 a square foot. Those two sales were three months apart, priced $88,000 apart and within about $12 a square foot of each other. Within the same building, the bigger unit cost more, while across town the gaps come from location.
Next door in Spring Lake, the land premium runs even higher. In the week of June 29, 909 Jersey Ave. there sold for $2,865,000 with 1,119 square feet, three bedrooms and one bath, which is over $2,500 a square foot. If you're cross-shopping these two towns, compare lots and locations, because comparing kitchens will mislead you.
The countywide numbers show what Belmar is priced against. For October 2026, New Jersey REALTORS reported a Monmouth County single-family median sale price of $844,450, up 7.7% from October 2025. Homes went under contract in 35 days on average, sellers received 100.7% of list price, and the 1,270 homes for sale equaled 3.0 months of supply. In the 2024 ACS estimates, the median value of an owner-occupied home in Belmar was $861,800, compared with $647,100 countywide.
The county condo figures show why a median can mislead. In October 2026, the Monmouth County townhouse-condo median jumped 17.2% from a year earlier to $644,376, while closed sales fell 7.4% and inventory rose 9.3%. Fewer sales and more supply don't usually point to prices climbing 17% across the board. A more likely reading is that a different mix of units sold this October than last October. That's the same trap a Belmar buyer faces with a town average. When the mix of lots behind the number shifts, the average moves even if no single property gained a dollar.
Why does a small, older Belmar house cost more than a bigger one a few blocks away? Belmar adds very few new houses, so buyers pay for the lot and its location. The house is a smaller part of the price. The summer and fall 2026 sales above show houses under 1,300 square feet closing above much larger houses elsewhere in town.
Are two-family and front-and-rear properties common in Belmar? Yes. The borough counts 444 units in two-unit structures out of 3,899 total, and several properties with a front house and a rear house came before the zoning board this fall. What one of these lots is worth depends on exactly what is on it, so get the details before you compare it with a single-family sale.
Does the condo market follow the same rules? Partly. Inside one building like 1700 Main Street, price tracks square footage closely. Across Belmar, the building's location does the same job a lot does for a house.
Thinking about selling a Belmar house that sits on one of those well-placed lots? Price it on the comps that match the land, not just the bedroom count. That's what Alexis Fraistat does. Start with a free home valuation and get a straight answer on what your lot is worth in this market.
I’m Alexis Fraistat – a single mom, a hustler, and a Realtor® who gets things DONE. From negotiating the best deals to guiding you through inspections, paperwork, and everything in between, I’m in it with you.